Up in the Old Hotel
Powered by Max Banner Ads
Mitchell explored a New York City that has now vanished in his four books and his classic reportage for The New Yorker. Mitchell’s eccentrics live again in this omnibus volume that contains all of his books and several previously uncollected stories.
User Ratings and Reviews
4 Stars An observer of people
Mitchell, a well-known reporter, has filled a role in history that will always be remembered and loved by those who lived the life he wrote about.
The people in his stories are unique and have qualities some would find interesting. His writing is very descriptive and he captures countless details not understood or seen by the casual passerby. You can easily place yourself as a fly on the wall soaking in your surroundings.
If you read Up in the Old Hotel with literary merit in mind, then you will be in for a good dose of excellent writing by a standard of yesteryear. If you are looking for people who fit outside the box, you will surely find them. If you are looking for a glimpse of the past, then be prepared to journey back with a fine guide who didn’t miss a thing.
There will be many of the older generation that will remember, with clarity, when Mitchell’s writings first appeared and the impact they made. It is to this group that I recommend Up in the Old Hotel.
Though a brilliant writer, I was not drawn to his stories. For me they lacked the “snap, crackle, and pop” of today’s aggressive writing style. If New York had been my home over the years, then I would have found a deeper appreciation and understanding for those who made up Mitchell’s fine work.
Armchair Interviews says: From a man who knew how to observe and then put it down on paper.
4 Stars Great reading!
A book that covers the nooks and crannies of lower Manhattan. Oddball characters are brought to full
bloom under the author’s pen. He knew how to listen! Towards the back some great essays on
growing up along the Carolina coast.
5 Stars Up In The Old Hotel by Joseph Mitchell
Joseph Mitchell, a fine writer for The New Yorker magazine, put together a wonderful grouping of short stories during his many years of searching out the people and interesting places in New York City which was his beat for many years. I highly recommend this book to those who enjoy a good story about ordinary people, or one of an interesting landmark s such as McSorley’s Bar and the people who frquented it during the 1920’s and 1930’s. It has been at the same location since 1854 and is still there today. My favorites are the first story, The Old House At Home (about Mcsorley’s) and Mr. Hunter’s Grave, towards the end of the book. Many others are excellent and bring out the heart of the city and its people. To me it brought back New York as it was then with kids “roasting mickies” as I did as a child in New York. G. H. Owens
5 Stars An American Classic
I have been known to complain that five star reviews are given out way too freely. In this case, however, five stars may not be enough. In fact, I am surprised that some reviewers ONLY gave this book four stars, but to each his own. Other reviews have already very eloquently praised this book, so I will not repeat them, except to confirm they are on target. The book is 716 pages, and I only wish it were longer. If you enjoy great writing, great storytelling, great (and real!) characters I could not imagine a better choice than Up In The Old Hotel. It also transports us to a different time and place in America, one that existed before I grew up, but one that this book almost makes you long for. If you do not read this book, all I can say is, it is your loss.
5 Stars Buy several
My father put me on to this book shortly after it was published. I recently ordered a copy from Amazon to give my son, an aspiring writer. This book is for anyone who appreciates good writing and, given that most of the pieces were written in the 1940’s, recent American cultural history. Good writing? No, it’s matchless. There’s a reason this book has 33 5-star reviews and two 4-stars. Read any of them, they’re all on the mark. Buy several copies; share the wealth.
